This is the question being debated in radio circles today. Should Mel Greig and Michael Christian lose their jobs over the prank call that allegedly led to a nurse at Kate Middleton's hospital taking her own life?
Put aside the emotion and the tragic outcome aside for a second. Let's think it through:
1. Prank calls by radio hosts is as old as the medium itself. This one didn't start out any different than tens of thousands of similar pranks played by announcers across the planet
2. There is no way--NO WAY--this call should have succeeded. The fact that people at the hospital fell for the gag--a claim that the Queen herself was on the phone, complete with a terrible, terrible accent--says more about them than the jocks making the call.
3. Before the nurse died, this gag was hailed as one of the great prank bits of all time. I don't know about that, but it was up there. It made global headlines, which is something of a Holy Grail for a radio station. Greig and Christian were radio heroes. Then someone died, apparently at her own hand, as a result of shame and embarrassment of being duped. This was totally unexpected and terribly, terribly sad.
4. And let's be very clear about the circumstances. If this prank call had not involved British royalty, we wouldn't even be talking about it.
So again I ask: should Greig and Christian be fired?
Click to read more ...